Skip to main content

Should I be laughing at this?

Inspired by my post yesterday by what we should and shouldn't laugh about – or at least what we should feel guilty about laughing about – I made a comment on another site that prompted some more thought on the topic.

Now I have to preface this with a statement about my sense of humour. I broadly accept the whole, "a joke is just a joke, don't get too precious about stuff" line. Indeed, I've told many an unsavoury joke and used it in defence of myself plenty of times. Also, I can't stand ultra sensitive types. These people generally bore me and appear to float about looking for something, anything, to get offended by, and thus giving themselves the opportunity to sermonise about their own moral superiority.

Yet I couldn't help myself making such a comment at another website yesterday, when reading yet another angry little rant on how dreadful Hillary Clinton would be as President, and spotting an ad for a t-shirt in the side bar that the site itself appeared to be selling. Here is a pic of the t-shirt in question:


And my comment read: "Nice sexist t-shirt there. How very progressive!"

Now, I copped a bit of flack by people who thought that I was being too sensitive, and needed to lighten up as it was "just a joke", albeit one in which they were making money out of. But the comment that I made was what I thought at the time, and that's what I still think.

Some context though. The page itself seems broadly 'progressive' - that is - if you extend the notion of 'progressive' to include simplistic Bush-hating, and general anti-Iraq War stuff. Yet, the anti-Clinton diatribe was of a type that I have read a bit of lately: from the (broad) 'left', defensive, angry, and full of lazy assumptions about her potential rooted in ideas about gender.

Now, to be totally honest with you, despite the whole Political Science degree, and a research background that had a particular focus on Bill Clinton's presidency, I frankly don't care that much about the pre-selection process of US elections (although you can't get away from it anywhere). I've already indicated that I'm on the Wiggum-Wagon, so I don't have any stake in it apart from that.

Now, I've already made a snide little remark on the whole Clinton/sexism thing and how the cult of Obama disturbs me. And maybe this is where it rubs against the grain for me. Racism is stupid; I can't put it any plainer than that. It doesn't make any sense to me to paint an entire race with the same brush. Yet so is sexism, for exactly the same reason. So maybe the problem that I have is that the Obama crowd seem to get getting upset at even the most minor hint of race-baiting, but seem totally flippant about what is pretty clear and offensive sexism (which the above t-shirt appears to be).

To look at it from another angle, look at the stir over the now-infamous Don Imus comments, how is that t-shirt all that different from what he said? If Clinton had a record of sexual promiscuity, maybe it wouldn't jar with me, but she doesn't.

So perhaps it's the double standard/hypocrisy that gets to me, rather than the sexism per sae. I can't say that I would be offended in this way without the extraneous stuff around the Clinton/Obama battle. I guess that it irritates even more so when it occurs in supposed 'progressive' forums.

What do people think?

Comments

The D in D & T said…
I completely agree with you. That t-shirt is totally sexist. I also found your comments on Obama in one of your previous posts particularly interesting. What do the promises mean? I think you make a very valid point - what does the Obama camp's HOPE actually look like and how is it going to be measured. I hadnt thought about it like that before I read your post. That being said, I can't really say that I support Hillary either.
Kris McCracken said…
The thing that worries me about Obama is the real lack of detail. I've seen his proposed health care policy, and it looks terrible. It won't make any difference at all. The rest is really meaningless guff. With Clinton - love or loathe her - you can have a fair idea on where she'll go based on prior actions. Obama is an unknown, and to be totally honest, I've no reason to see why an upper middle class career corporate lawyer will offer anything too different from any other candidate, whatever his (deliberate emphasis) race might be.
Anonymous said…
Very true. I'm very tired of the sexism towards Clinton and (over here) Julia Gillard.

I have to admit that both Democratic camps seem to be finding racism or sexism baiting comments from the other candidate, yet ignoring everything John McCain says.
Kris McCracken said…
It's a very odd system where all of the pre-selection is done in the open. Parties spend a year at each other's throats doing the work of their opposition.

We've seen how it isn't that helpful in Australia with the ongoing leadership tensions in the ALP with Beazley's crowd destabilising Crean, then Latham, then Beazley gets the job, but resentments over his past activities saw disunity and eventually it takes everyone pulling their heads in presenting a broad face under Rudd to get in power.

Politics being politics though, I'd wager that we'll see (and are already seeing) the same thing with the Libs. Watch as Turnbull, Abbott, Hockey and whoever else do to Nelson what happened to Crean.

It’s one of the key reasons that I’m not keen at all on an elected President in Australia, as there doesn’t appear to be any way to avoid this sort of thing.

Popular posts from this blog

Lost inside an adorable illusion and I cannot hide, I'm the one you're using, please don't push me aside, we could've made it cruising, yeah.

Yes it is Theme Thusday again, and today we are talking GLASS . I've three possible hooks to hang my [glass] hat on with this theme. First, the photo! Yes, it is the river again from an odd angle in an interesting light. You can just make out the bottom, which should tell you that I'm right on the shore. In some ways, the distortion of the stones below the surface reminds me of ye olde glass windows, what they call "cylinder blown sheet glass". You can still find some of this around Hobart these days. Thw second link comes from a trip I took to Venice a few years back. You're probably aware that Venice was (is?) a glass-making centre of excellence. If you have ever been there and taken the tour of the glass factories, you might be familiar with the sheer amount of coloured glass that sits at the bottom of the water there. These fragments of glass have been worn down and had their edges dulled by their time in the water, which makes them ample keepsakes for the ...

Hold me now, oh hold me now, until this hour has gone around. And I'm gone on the rising tide, to face Van Dieman's Land

Theme Thursday again, and this one is rather easy. I am Tasmanian, you see, and aside from being all around general geniuses - as I have amply described previously - we are also very familiar with the concept of WATER. Tasmania is the ONLY island state of an ISLAND continent. That means, we're surrounded by WATER. That should help explain why I take so many photographs of water . Tasmania was for a long time the place where the British (an island race terrified of water) sent their poor people most vile and horrid criminals. The sort of folk who would face the stark choice of a death sentence , or transportation to the other end of the world. Their catalogue of crimes is horrifying : stealing bread assault stealing gentlemen's handkerchiefs drunken assault being poor affray ladies being overly friendly with gentlemen for money hitting people having a drink and a laugh public drunkenness being Irish Fenian terrorist activities being Catholic religious subversion. ...

Happy anniversary baby, got you on my mind

No it is not a webcam, but this photograph was taken a mere forty-five ago on my way in to work. Here you can see a good old fashioned Hobart autumn morning, with the rain pelting down and me getting drenched. This one was taken on the corner of Macquarie and Elizabeth, while I was waiting for the lights to change. Come on Ampelmännchen ! Today is my wedding anniversary, an apparently I need to be showering Jen with leather -related goodies. Va-va-vaVOOM! To you Jennifer, here is a poem I wrote this very morning. Anniversary I love you i love you iloveyouiloveyouiloveyou I LOVE you I love YOU iloveyouiloveyouiloveyou I LOVE YOU iloveyouiloveyouiloveyou Happy anniversary