As I have banged on about of late, I've been in attendance at a conference for the past three days. Over the course, I've had the privilege of seeing some world class brains on a variety of issues do excellent and engaging presentations, and then there were others who maybe were something less.
No different from any conference then! I began jotting a few questions that I would suggest future presenters read and think about before they get around to deliver the talk. In part, this began as a bit of a venting process during poor presentations, but upon reflection, I actually think that each point is actually quite valid. Even (especially) the ones written in frustration.
So here they are, my list of things to think about when preparing a presentation:
No different from any conference then! I began jotting a few questions that I would suggest future presenters read and think about before they get around to deliver the talk. In part, this began as a bit of a venting process during poor presentations, but upon reflection, I actually think that each point is actually quite valid. Even (especially) the ones written in frustration.
So here they are, my list of things to think about when preparing a presentation:
- What are you trying to say?
- Is it worth saying?
- Have you actually thought about what it is that you will say?
- Is there anything new or original in what it is that you have to say?
- Are you attempting to construct an argument?
- If so, does it progress in a logical manner?
- If not, is it worth presenting at a conference?
- Have you considered what material may be unnecessary?
- Are you prepared to discard all that which is unnecessary?
- If not, why not?
- Have you considered whether anyone will be interested in what it is that you have to say?
- Are you interested in what it is that you have to say?
- If not, why bother saying it?
- Have you considered the relevance (or otherwise) of the material that you wish to present?
- Have you ‘tested’ you material on anyone?
- If not, why not?
- Are you comfortable talking about the topic that you intend to talk about in a general setting?
- If not, why have you chosen to present on this topic?
- Will you be reading directly from prepared notes?
- If so, is this absolutely necessary?
- Do you intend to engage eye contact with anyone through the course of your presentation?
- Have you given any thought on visual aids?
- Are you going to use PowerPoint?
- Why are you using PowerPoint?
- Have you given any specific thought to the material that you are including in your PowerPoint presentation?
- If not, why are you using PowerPoint?
- If so, have you really given thought to your PowerPoint slides? REALLY?
- Do you feel that 50 slides in a 25-minute presentation is an effective use of PowerPoint?
- Is a floral theme appropriate for charts tracking mortality rates?
- Are ‘themed slides’ EVER appropriate for conference papers?
- How much information are you loading onto your graphics?
- How much do you think is too much?
- How long will you leave each slide up?
- Is this enough time?
- If not, do you really need the visual aide?
- Have you considered altering the tone and inflection of your voice at any point in your talk?
- What about movement? Do you plan to move at all?
- If not, why not? Do you have a specific reason for standing still throughout the presentation?
- Are you at all interested in engaging your audience?
- Have you given any thought about how you might go about engaging you audience?
- Have you given any thought to what engages you as an audience member?
- Are you familiar with the notion of a ‘colourful anecdote’?
- Have you considered the appropriateness (or otherwise) of any ‘colourful anecdote/s’ you are thinking of using?
- Are you aware of the dangers of condescension?
- Have you considered whether any of the comments that you intend to make are libellous?
- If so, are these comments really necessary?
- Are you familiar with the concept of ‘self-deprecation’ and its ability to ease tension within an audience?
- Do you have a significant fear of speaking in front of a group of people?
- Have you thought about what those fears are grounded in?
- Have you thought about whether someone else in your department or organisation might be better placed to deliver a public presentation?
- Have you considered doing a poster?
- Have you checked your PowerPoint presentation for spelling and grammar?
- Are you familiar with the rules around using apostrophes?
- Are you familiar with apostrophe?
- Do you plan to cry during your presentation?
- If so, could you try not to?
- Do you intend on introducing further questions for the audience to take away with them to consider?
- If not, can you think of any that may stimulate people to think about your work after you have finished?
- WHAT are you saying?
- WHY are you saying it?
- HOW are you saying it?
- WHY are you saying it HOW you are saying it?
- Is it still worth saying?
- Will people benefit from hearing it?
- Is this the best way of saying it?
- Has this process aided in any way of saying it better?
Comments
I think all your points about presentations have much merit...and I wish that when I went to professional development days the speakers would all follow your guidelines in making a presentation less boring! Perhaps you could hold a conference and do a presentation about this very thing!?? haha
I guess the key thing for me is that I don't mind talking in front of large groups, I've pretty much concentrated on this one topic (clinical supervision) for the past 6 months, so really, if I couldn't stand up and talk about it in a vaguely interesting way for only 25 minutes, well, I shouldn't be in the job!
The biggest problem that I had was in balancing some very real criticisms of the group of organisations that I've been working worth (most of who had representatives there), with delivering an overall message that was positive. I think that I got the balance about as right as I could, but who knows?
I get the feeling that some of my remarks were more 'cutting' then perhaps this sector is used to, but hey, they have needed a real boot up the backside for a long time.
I would be really interested to hear about your work one day..I'd love to know all about what you do...it is such an interesting field.
What organisations do you work with?
I've never really understood how some of the lecturers that I've seen through university are so poor at public speaking when they've done it for years and years. It really isn't that hard. And to be honest, if they say "oh I just don't like doing it" I can't help but think "why enter this industry then"? I'm not too keen on snakes, so I wouldn't go and get a job in a reptile park!
I'll send you a Facebook breakdown of what I do all day. It will bore you to tears!
Glad you included the apostrophe, since it always seems to be put in the wrong place by Australians.
Good to read more about you here in the comments too.
Anyway Dina, I see that you're learning Arabic, now THAT would be a challenge! Languages are a lot of work, especially learning to read and write in them.
I will admit that at least half of these came to me during a dire speech by a bureaucrat who had appeared to have cut and paste random snippets of policy and blunder through reading them (broken up, of course, with plenty of 'ums' and 'ahs').
ptowngirl
HamptonRoadsDailyPhoto.com
1. Talk directly off the powerpoint
2. WRITE the whole fricking talk down and then READ the blooming thing....
I have always been taught that if you are using visual aids they should ENHANCE your talk, not detract from them....